Most citizens have a reasonable idea of the basic services municipalities should provide and don’t look too closely at their municipality, its budget and spending until something goes wrong. Even then, finding the necessary information could take many hours of analysing complicated reports, financial statements, and other documents, and would only be possible for someone who has a certain level of financial literacy.
But now Municipal Money, a new website tool built for National Treasury by OpenUp makes this information for all South African municipalities accessible in an easy-understand format with a few clicks of a mouse. The site also links to all the original Treasury source documents allowing anyone with the requisite skills to dig deeper.
It is searchable by municipality or street address, and it also allows side-by-side comparisons between two municipalities.
For example, at the end of 2015, the town Oudtshoorn in the Western Cape had a negative cash balance of over R60-million and it was not even able to cover a single day of its day-to-day expenses.
In the last four years the municipality has spent nothing at all on repairs and maintenance, which has heavily affected service delivery in the area. And the total it spent on operating expenses is unknown, as the municipality failed to report to Treasury for the 2014/2015 financial year.
This is clearly a municipality in dire straits.
Simpler and easier
Normally, this information would not be easily available to the public. Now, Municipal Money gives citizens the information and ability to hold municipalities to account if they are not performing.
“The creation of this portal is in response to the commitment made by the Minister in his 2016 Budget speech to launch a data portal that will provide stakeholders with municipal financial information, in order to stimulate citizen involvement in local governance,” according to a Treasury statement.
“It is also in line with international best practice, in terms of which governments are increasingly opening up their data to the public and specifically budget data - to promote oversight, transparency and accountability.”
Says Greg Kempe, head of technology at OpenUp, which built the tool:
“National Treasury does a good job of making information available, but there’s a difference between that and understanding the information. The goal is to use technology to bridge that gap. People can see financial performance indicators in a way that are easy to understand, whether they’re good at reading financial information or not.
“Monitoring the performance of municipalities should be an ongoing conversation and not just limited to election time”, says Kempe. “Residents often engage with their municipalities at the edges: when paying their rates and when things aren’t working. In reality, municipalities provide an enormous number of services and need to be run effectively. It’s our job as residents to understand what their obligations are and to see if they provide the services up to the level that we’re happy with.”
But analysing information that makes holding municipalities accountable is often left to those with a little more financial nous. Municipal Money removes the middle-man, even providing contact numbers for municipal officials.
Adi Eyal, director of OpenUp, says that while local budget information has always been accessible, it’s difficult for most people to understand what it means – for example, do the numbers mean the municipality is doing well or not?
Municipal Money is neutral on the state of municipalities, but rather shows whether spending is “good” or “bad” based on defined indicators that have been identified by government.
The collaboration between National Treasury and OpenUp fits within the context of an Open Government Partnership – an international movement that aims to connect civil society with governments to make them more transparent, says Eyal.
“This is an opportunity to help citizens become more aware, more engaged and more involved in holding local government accountable.”
The website “puts a friendly face to complex data”, presenting it in a way that users can assess what the numbers mean. The tool is aimed at a wide variety of users, including media, civil society, ratepayers’ associations and activists, and software developers.
The data behind the website is provided by the National Treasury, who receive it from municipalities.
In addition to the website, the data is available from municipaldata.treasury.gov.za and can be downloaded in Excel and CSV formats, or in machine-friendly JSON form, allowing others to build their own interactive applications.
Ultimately, it is about empowering ordinary people with the skills “to better understand the budgeting process for local government, and to participate in the creation of budgets”, says Eyal.